Here's a fun game to play with a recent college graduate or dedicated liberal (but I repeat myself): Ask her if there is ever a situation in which rape can be excused.
After the ensuing five minutes of "sexist pig, how could you ask such a disgusting question?!" when (if) she has calmed down, repeat the question, and ask for a serious answer.
The answer, of course, will be "No."
The answer should be No. There is never any situation in which rape is excusable. It is an evil act.
Which is the point of the exercise.
Morality is a difficult topic to discuss today. Morality has become so relative, that any discussion of it turns into a psychologist session ("Well, I feel...")
Even discussing the idea of moral relativism as a phenomenon is difficult. There are so few areas of morality about which everybody can agree, thus it is hard to get past the manifestations of moral relativism to the issue of moral relativity itself.
There seem to be only two areas of absolute evil about which everybody can agree. The first example, oft cited, are the Nazis and the atrocities they committed during World War II. The attribution of "Nazi" to politicians of both sides illustrates the universal recognition of the Nazis' evil. However, this example does not work for the purpose of the exercise. World War II is too distant history for many people today. Though the evil can be recognized, it is far removed and does not seem real.
That leaves rape.
The "campus rape culture" has brought the issue of rape to the forefront of the national consciousness. While the extent to which such a culture exists can be debated, the question of whether or not rape itself is a terrible evil cannot be. Just ask any college co-ed.
Which brings us back, again, to the point of the exercise.
Once a person can admit that there are issues about which there is no debate of morality, it is not such a leap to accept that there are other area of universal truths. If it is true in one area of life, it is only logical that such universality can be found in other areas of life. Theft. Drug use. Cheating. Religious extremism.
This exercise does not promise instant transformation from Liberal to Conservative, Atheist to believer (I'd have to charge if I knew of such a thing.) But it is a step in that direction.
If nothing else, it is common ground from which to begin a civil conversation. These days, that cannot be taken for granted.
After the ensuing five minutes of "sexist pig, how could you ask such a disgusting question?!" when (if) she has calmed down, repeat the question, and ask for a serious answer.
The answer, of course, will be "No."
The answer should be No. There is never any situation in which rape is excusable. It is an evil act.
Which is the point of the exercise.
Morality is a difficult topic to discuss today. Morality has become so relative, that any discussion of it turns into a psychologist session ("Well, I feel...")
Even discussing the idea of moral relativism as a phenomenon is difficult. There are so few areas of morality about which everybody can agree, thus it is hard to get past the manifestations of moral relativism to the issue of moral relativity itself.
There seem to be only two areas of absolute evil about which everybody can agree. The first example, oft cited, are the Nazis and the atrocities they committed during World War II. The attribution of "Nazi" to politicians of both sides illustrates the universal recognition of the Nazis' evil. However, this example does not work for the purpose of the exercise. World War II is too distant history for many people today. Though the evil can be recognized, it is far removed and does not seem real.
That leaves rape.
The "campus rape culture" has brought the issue of rape to the forefront of the national consciousness. While the extent to which such a culture exists can be debated, the question of whether or not rape itself is a terrible evil cannot be. Just ask any college co-ed.
Which brings us back, again, to the point of the exercise.
Once a person can admit that there are issues about which there is no debate of morality, it is not such a leap to accept that there are other area of universal truths. If it is true in one area of life, it is only logical that such universality can be found in other areas of life. Theft. Drug use. Cheating. Religious extremism.
This exercise does not promise instant transformation from Liberal to Conservative, Atheist to believer (I'd have to charge if I knew of such a thing.) But it is a step in that direction.
If nothing else, it is common ground from which to begin a civil conversation. These days, that cannot be taken for granted.
Comments
Post a Comment