The Straw Man of the Transgender Bathroom Debate

 

     With the passing of the so-called bathroom bill in North Carolina, which states that "every multiple occupancy bathroom or changing facility that is designated for student use to be designated for and used only by students based on their biological sex" (read the full text here), many celebrities, businesses, and even municipalities (LA, NY, and others) have boycotted the state entirely. Singers have cancelled scheduled performances in North Carolina. The NBA is contemplating moving the 2017 All-Star Game away from Charlotte, in protest of the law.

       Meanwhile, stores such as Target have taken the opposite stance, proudly proclaiming that they "welcome transgender team members and guests to use the restroom or fitting room facility that corresponds with their gender identity." (Target Press Release). In response to their decision, some 700,00 people have pledged to boycott Target.

     People have taken to social media to scoff at the protesters, calling them "crazies" and considering themselves lucky that they will no longer have to shop with members of the ACA. They argue that no evidence suggests that transgender people pose any threat to women or children in restrooms. One example here)
 
     This is the ultimate straw man. Nobody has ever suggested that transgender individuals are predators. The concern is that predators will take the opportunity offered by places like Target to cause harm to women and children. In fact, this is the main reason for the boycott, as expressed by many on social media (Twitter examples).
 
    (Curious, isn't it, that few if any people comment on the potential threat to men caused by women using men's restrooms?)
 
     Though there is some validity to it, and certainly some people truly believe the reasoning, the real issue here is not the safety of women and children (and men). That argument is used by supporters of the boycott to sound legitimate, in the hopes that their views will not be dismissed as hateful and bigoted.
 
      The real issue is that Target's "inclusive" policy inherently excludes people who are uncomfortable sharing a bathroom or changing room with someone of the opposite sex. Target is alienating many of its customers in favor of 0.3% of the U.S. population (ABC News). So whose comfort is more important?

    If there is a transgender individual who takes hormones and dresses or looks like the sex with which they identify, few would have a problem with them using the bathroom with which they identify. Probably because they would not even know it is a transgender individual. Basically, they would see a woman entering a women's restroom, or a man entering a men's.
 
     And that is the ultimate issue. Men are not allowed in women's bathrooms, and vice versa. This has become a more complicated issue in 2016 than it was even 50 years ago. But a line has to be drawn somewhere, and both North Carolina and Target have chosen a spot to draw theirs.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

It's not blaming the victim

Google Doodles

Stop with the Race!