Rioting Misses the Point
Before a point can be argued, terms must be defined for a productive discussion to be had.
For the purposes of this essay:
Protestor: a person who peacefully advocates for a specific cause, either through marching, writing, sit-ins, or other non-confrontational means.
Rioter: a person who violently destroys private or public property, confronts others violently, whether or not there is a cause they are forwarding.
Protesting is an important American right. We often take freedom of speech for granted, not recognizing how special it is. The ability to criticize the government and others without fear of incarceration or death, is a liberty and luxury not enjoyed everywhere in the world. We should celebrate and exercise this right.
George Floyd was inhumanely killed. This is something that everyone agrees with. The officers involved should be investigated and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Whether or not it was racially motivated is harder to determine, because it is not possible to know exactly what is in someone's mind or heart, unless the officers admit to it.
Even if it was not a racially motivated act, it was an unjust demonstration of police brutality. The United States is a democratic-republic, and it is right that an act of this nature be protested. We want the government and police to know that this sort of brutality will not be tolerated. Protesting country-wide in response is valid.
Rioting, on the other hand, is completely counter to who we are as a nation and to the stated mission of groups like Black Lives Matter. And, whether or not the rioters are primarily members of Black Lives Matter, of groups like antifa, or are unaffiliated, the Black Lives Matter name is the one most out there, so they will be the ones taking the brunt of the backlash.
Rioting is immoral. Destroying public or personal property - even in theoretical protest of some wrong- is contrary to the American way of life. Our rights extend just as far as the next person. If you decide to disrupt another person's life, then you breach that social contract and have drifted into the illegal/immoral category.
If Black lives matter, then they should matter in life as much as in death. That means rioting that frightens black children, disrupts black lives, and destroys black livelihoods is in direct opposition to Black Lives Matter. Murders at the hands of police are tragic and obviously forever impact the lives of the victim's family. But there are living people, of all races, whose lives are being destroyed because of rioting.
Supposedly, rioting of this kind is meant to "take down a racist system." But when you destroy a small business, you don't take down THE man, you take down A man (or woman) who has worked hard to start and run a business to support him/herself and family. Maybe that's a lifelong dream that you are ruining.
And in response to those who say (and somehow there are people who say this): "Well, losing a business is not as big deal as losing your life" I would respond "Duh." Is anybody saying that losing your livelihood is worse than being killed? No. When the mugger comes to you on the street and says, "Your money or your life," you give up your money. But the choice here wasn't between George Floyd's money or his life. It wasn't even a choice. It was George Floyd's life and some innocent fireman's money. You wouldn't say to a woman beaten by her husband "A kid was raped yesterday, so your situation looks like pretty small peanuts now, doesn't it?" They are two separate crimes. Whether or not they are equally bad on an absolute level, that is for the courts and God to decide. But to each individual victim, their own situation is unbearable.
There are times when violence can be absolutely necessary and can fix a specific problem. If a thief is picking your pocket, you jab him in the ribs to get rid of him. Maybe throw in a few punches and he gets the message: leave this guy alone. Direct violence, as a means of self-protection, directed toward the actual perpetrator, makes a strong point. But misdirected violence against innocent civilians... rioters, you have become the mugger, not the muggee.
If people had only protested, their words might have been heard. If they only posted words of solidarity on social media, instead of verbally attacking and denouncing those who chose not to post, they may have been listened to. If people had only boycotted businesses instead of burning and looting, their opinions might have been given credence. Instead, people chose to get violent. Now, all people will remember is the violence and destruction, which dishonors the memory of George Floyd.
Comments
Post a Comment