A Response to Utter Stupidity
A recent Bookriot.com article by Mikkaka Overstreet recommends the best books to teach you about Judaism (so your Jewish friends don’t have to). Overstreet is not Jewish. However, there is nothing wrong with a non-Jew suggesting books that teach Judaism. In fact, as a non-Jew, Overstreet has a different perspective on what books might be most helpful for someone who isn’t Jewish to learn about Judaism.
She reasons
that her version of a list is necessary because she does not think it the
responsibility of Jews to enlighten Christians, “just
as it is not the responsibility of people of color to teach white people about
racism or for queer people to educate the straights.” This is where she goes
wrong. It is absolutely the responsibility of Jews to educate non-Jews: it is
our explicit role to be a “light unto the nations.” Hard to be a light if we’re
waiting for other people to turn on the switch. It is necessary for any group
to teach the world about themselves. Whether it is directly through
conversations or indirectly through books, peoples should have the opportunity
and embrace the responsibility to educate others about their own experiences.
Otherwise, the possibility for misinformation and misunderstanding is
amplified.
Overstreet
further contradicts herself by recommending books written by Jews. In her
explanation, it is not Jews who needn’t explain Judaism to non-Jews; rather, it
is that one should not ask one’s friends about their own religion. better to
learn it second hand through a book than directly from the source. Now, it may
be that one does not have a friend to ask, in which case turning to a good
book, like Joseph Telushkin’s Jewish Literacy, is a better option than
Wikipedia. Nonetheless, she is advocating for non-Jews to learn about Judaism
from Jews.
As a Jew, I would much
prefer my non-Jewish friends ask me questions about Judaism, just as I would
want to ask them questions about their own religion. If I do not know an
answer, I can refer them to a book or Rabbi. But, isn’t it better to talk
directly to the source? Why is it preferable to search Google for the answer to
what Kosher is or how to celebrate Purim than to ask a friend or coworker? Asking
a friend encourages communication and understanding. In Overstreet’s world of
reading about it, people would maybe gain an academic understanding of
different people, but the human connection would be missing. And isn’t the
missing human connection the problem?
Overstreet
also commented on the fact that she has “heard enough blah blah blah about how
the United States is a Christian nation”. The United States is a
Christian nation, in that its founding was based on Judeo-Christian principles
and the majority religion is Christianity. It is a Christian nation in its culture,
not its government, which makes all the difference. Because it is not a
Christian government, there is also the other truth that the Unites States
supports religious freedom and is home to people of every religion. Overstreet
comments that the United States has the largest Jewish population outside of
Israel. True, but Jews are still a tiny fraction of the U.S. population.
One more thing: Overstreet refers to groups of people as folx. Folks is an inclusive term than encompasses all people, we don’t need to turn language into an algebra problem.
Comments
Post a Comment